Tales of Myspace’s difficult to use and ugly backend were always floating around my ears although I’d never used it, now I have. The stories weren’t exaggerated at all. I consider myself an experienced user of all types of applications, online or offline, that’s able to quickly learn and become comfortable with a new system.
When I bought my first Macintosh worries about having to learn a new operating system never even crossed my mind. When it had to go back to the shop, not wanting to go back to Windows for a week, I tried out Ubuntu and had no trouble finding my way around. I even set up a dual boot between KDE and Gnome to see what each was like and was quickly comfortable in both. That said, the Myspace backend is really hard to use and I’m still not comfortable.
If you’re able to use Myspace with no trouble at all you’ve gotten yourself into some really bad habits. Working around Myspace is really difficult, holes need to be jumped through over and over again. It’s laborious to use, it’s hard work. Why people have stuck with something so difficult to use I can’t understand. If you haven’t used Myspace before this is the login screen.

Find the login form! At the very top of the page is a web search. Let’s think about a typical use of Myspace. A user has typed in the Myspace URL, are they there to use Myspace or are they there to perform a web search? Yet the very first thing on the page is a web search.
Then there’s the advertising, two huge ads built into the content area. If you think that’s bad let’s wait until we hit your personal admin area.
On the other hand, there’s Facebook. I’ve been using Facebook for a little longer than Myspace and the use has been far more frequent, I really enjoy using Facebook. Facebook has nearly identical basic functionality to Myspace, you have friends, you have a wall for people to leave comments on, there’s photos, a little information about you, etc. Let’s have a look at the Facebook home/login screen compared to Myspace’s.

Look what the very first element is, the login screen. I could take a guess that 90% of users coming to this page are returning visitors and that all of those are at that page to login. The other 10% would be there for the first time, for them, there’s a little about what Facebook is and an obvious option to register. Apart from those two things, there is nothing else, not even an ad.
I kept a bit of whitespace at the bottom in the screenshot because I wanted to demonstrate the space they could have potentially taken up, but didn’t. Here’s each applications home page, the first screen after logging in.


Again with the web search on Myspace, did the user just go to Myspace and login to do a web search? Must have, Anything else on Myspace is way to hard. Facebook’s admin area is brilliantly organised, the left column contains a Facebook search and all your own information. the centre news feed contains recent things your Facebook friends have done, something you may really be interested in. The right column is secondary information that doesn’t fit in either other column.
Myspace’s admin screen is so full of useless bullshit it’s hard to comprehend. You have to scroll down to see if you have any new friend requests or message. Of course the prime real estate up the top is reserved for massive advertising. For a minute I thought I was on ANZ’s website. Cool new people? There’s 128 million people in my network? The date? Who cares. It’s just useless shit filling up space.
I could go on forever but really Facebook is now open to everyone, not just university students. Please consider ditching Myspace for Facebook and telling all your friends to do the same. Facebook do a lot of things right and I’d love to see them rewarded for it.